资源稀缺对消费行为的双刃剑效应:研究框架与展望

The Double-edged Sword Effect of Resource Scarcity on Consumer Behavior: Research Framework and Prospects

安薪如,刘楠,车敬上,王海侠,李爱梅

2021 第 43 卷 第 10 期 页码 103-119

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210718.301

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

消费者经常会产生已拥有资源少于所需要资源的主观感受,这种主观感受被称为资源稀缺。已有研究发现资源稀缺可产生双刃剑效应:一方面,可能会抑制个体对其他重要信息的关注,进而产生“管窥负担”;另一方面,也可能会使个体专注于使稀缺资源发挥最大价值,进而获得“专注红利”。通过文献梳理,本文首先综述了资源稀缺的定义、操纵方式及测量方式;其次,重点分消费前、消费中、消费后三个阶段总结了资源稀缺影响消费行为的双刃剑效应,并且开创性地从“开源”“节流”及“代偿”三条路径阐明了双刃剑效应产生的内在机制;接下来,从环境和个体两个层面梳理了资源稀缺影响消费行为的边界条件;最后,为消费者、商家及政策制定者提出了实践建议,并指明了未来的研究方向。

Resource scarcity, widespread in the acquisitive modern society, is a subjective feeling of less possession than necessity. Previous studies have suggested that resource scarcity will make individuals focus more on urgent things in the decision-making process, and eventually produce two different outcomes. One is named “tunneling tax”, that is, focusing on urgent things and inhibiting other goals, which eventually leads to adverse consequences. The other is named “focus dividend” that refers to the phenomenon of focusing on and maximizing the use of scarce resources, and ultimately generating favorable results.

Will the impact of resource scarcity on consumer behavior also present a double-edged effect? According to the classification of consumption decision-making process model, this paper systematically explicates the double-edged effect of the impact of resource scarcity on consumer behavior. It finds that the double-edged sword effect of resource scarcity on consumer behavior is reflected in the whole process of consumer decision-making. Specifically, before consumption, resource scarcity enables consumers to attain more promotional offers, but it also makes consumers ignore other important information and products. During consumption, resource scarcity causes the high utilization of scarce resources, while it may also lead consumers into a negative cycle of loan. After purchase, resource scarcity increases consumers’ attention on the use value of products, while it may also reduce the utilization of the social value of products.

This paper also explores the theories that explain the impact of resource scarcity on consumer behavior, and finds that the attention resource theory, the self-regulation theory and the emotion regulation strategy can explain the double-edged effect of consumer behavior from cognitive, behavioral and emotional levels. By further refining the process of resource scarcity affecting consumer behavior, it is found that resource scarcity can affect consumer behavior through three paths. The first is the “income-increasing” path, where consumers directly obtain scarce resources and easily incur the tunneling tax. The second is the “expenditure-reducing” path, where consumers tend to reduce the consumption of scarce resources, thus using them more efficiently and generating a focus dividend. The third is the “compensatory” path, where consumers tend to pursue other positive feelings. If consumers pursue only happiness, there will be a tunneling tax; if consumers actively pursue other goals than happiness, there will be a focus dividend. The three paths under the guidance of three theoretical foundations can fully explain how resource scarcity affects the double-edged effect of consumer behavior.

This paper also sorts out the moderators acting on the three paths from the environmental level or the individual level. Among them, information representation and the type of welfare system at the environmental level and cognitive resources at the individual level will moderate the “income-increasing” path and reduce the generation of tunneling tax. The location of goods will affect the “expenditure-reducing” path, which in turn increases the focus dividend. Resource mutability at the environmental level and the total amount of “slack” at the individual level will moderate the “compensatory” path, directly influencing the choice of consumers on this path.

In the end, this paper further provides practical inspiration for consumers, merchants and policy-makers to encourage them to utilize and deal with this effect effectively. Besides, future researches could explore the immediate and long-term effects of different types of resource scarcity on consumer behavior, as well as additional relevant moderators.

参考文献

5 Baldini M, Gallo G, Torricelli C. The scars of scarcity in the short run: An empirical investigation across Europe[J]. Economia Politica,2020, 37(3): 1033-1069. DOI:10.1007/s40888-020-00187-4
6 Banerjee A V, Duflo E. The economic lives of the poor[J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives,2007, 21(1): 141-168. DOI:10.1257/jep.21.1.141
7 Bhutta N, Goldin J, Homonoff T. Consumer borrowing after payday loan bans[J]. The Journal of Law and Economics,2016, 59(1): 225-259. DOI:10.1086/686033
8 Bratanova B, Loughnan S, Klein O, et al. Poverty, inequality, and increased consumption of high calorie food: Experimental evidence for a causal link[J]. Appetite,2016, 100: 162-171. DOI:10.1016/j.appet.2016.01.028
9 Briers B, Laporte S. A wallet full of calories: The effect of financial dissatisfaction on the desire for food energy[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2013, 50(6): 767-781. DOI:10.1509/jmr.10.0513
10 Bruner J S, Goodman C C. Value and need as organizing factors in perception[J]. The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology,1947, 42(1): 33-44. DOI:10.1037/h0058484
11 Cannon C, Goldsmith K, Roux C. A self-regulatory model of resource scarcity[J]. Journal of Consumer Psychology,2019, 29(1): 104-127. DOI:10.1002/jcpy.1035
12 Carvalho L S, Meier S, Wang S W. Poverty and economic decision-making: Evidence from changes in financial resources at payday[J]. American Economic Review,2016, 106(2): 260-284. DOI:10.1257/aer.20140481
13 Chaplin L N, Hill R P, John D R. Poverty and materialism: A look at impoverished versus affluent children[J]. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing,2014, 33(1): 78-92.
14 DeVoe S E, Pfeffer J. Time is tight: How higher economic value of time increases feelings of time pressure[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2011, 96(4): 665-676. DOI:10.1037/a0022148
15 Durante K M, Griskevicius V, Redden J P, et al. Spending on daughters versus sons in economic recessions[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2015, 42(3): 435-457. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucv023
16 Fan L Y, Li X N, Jiang Y W. Room for opportunity: Resource scarcity increases attractiveness of range marketing offers[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2019, 46(1): 82-98. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucy059
17 Floccia C, Butler J, Goslin J, et al. Regional and foreign accent processing in English: Can listeners adapt?[J]. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research,2009, 38(4): 379-412. DOI:10.1007/s10936-008-9097-8
18 Gelman S A, Echelbarger M E. Children, object value, and persuasion[J]. Journal of Consumer Psychology,2019, 29(2): 309-327. DOI:10.1002/jcpy.1097
19 Gilly M C, Gelb B D. Post-purchase consumer processes and the complaining consumer[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,1982, 9(3): 323-328. DOI:10.1086/208927
20 Griskevicius V, Ackerman J M, Cantú S M, et al. When the economy falters, do people spend or save? Responses to resource scarcity depend on childhood environments[J]. Psychological Science,2013, 24(2): 197-205. DOI:10.1177/0956797612451471
21 Griskevicius V, Tybur J M, Gangestad S W, et al. Aggress to impress: Hostility as an evolved context-dependent strategy[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2009, 96(5): 980-994. DOI:10.1037/a0013907
22 Hamilton R, Mittal C, Shah A, et al. How financial constraints influence consumer behavior: An integrative framework[J]. Journal of Consumer Psychology,2019a, 29(2): 285-305. DOI:10.1002/jcpy.1074
23 Hamilton R, Thompson D, Bone S, et al. The effects of scarcity on consumer decision journeys[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,2019b, 47(3): 532-550. DOI:10.1007/s11747-018-0604-7
24 Hill R P. Does research on scarcity apply to impoverished consumers?[J]. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research,2020, 5(4): 439-443. DOI:10.1086/709908
25 Hill R P, Stephens D L. Impoverished consumers and consumer behavior: The case of AFDC mothers[J]. Journal of Macromarketing,1997, 17(2): 32-48. DOI:10.1177/027614679701700204
27 Jennings L, Mathai M, Linnemayr S, et al. Economic context and HIV vulnerability in adolescents and young adults living in urban slums in Kenya: A qualitative analysis based on scarcity theory[J]. AIDS and Behavior,2017, 21(9): 2784-2798. DOI:10.1007/s10461-017-1676-y
28 Kapoor A, Tripathi S. The impact of time-keeping direction on compensatory consumption: The role of perceived resource deficiency[J]. Journal of Consumer Psychology,2020, 30(3): 534-542. DOI:10.1002/jcpy.1149
29 Layous K, Kurtz J, Chancellor J, et al. Reframing the ordinary: Imagining time as scarce increases well-being[J]. The Journal of Positive Psychology,2018, 13(3): 301-308. DOI:10.1080/17439760.2017.1279210
30 Mani A, Mullainathan S, Shafir E, et al. Poverty impedes cognitive function[J]. Science,2013, 341(6149): 976-980. DOI:10.1126/science.1238041
31 Mauss I B, Tamir M. Emotion goals: How their content, structure, and operation shape emotion regulation[A]. Gross J J. Handbook of emotion regulation[M]. New York: The Guilford Press, 2014.
32 Mehta R, Zhu M. Creating when you have less: The impact of resource scarcity on product use creativity[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2016, 42(5): 767-782. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucv051
33 Miller G A. The magical number seven, plus or minus two: Some limits on our capacity for processing information[J]. Psychological Review,1956, 63(2): 81-97. DOI:10.1037/h0043158
34 Mittal C, Griskevicius V. Silver spoons and platinum plans: How childhood environment affects adult health care decisions[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2016, 43(4): 636-656. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucw046
35 Mittal C, Laran J, Griskevicius V. How early-life resource scarcity influences self-confidence and task completion judgments[J]. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research,2020, 5(4): 404-414. DOI:10.1086/709884
36 Moeini-Jazani M, Albalooshi S, Seljeseth I M. Self-affirmation reduces delay discounting of the financially deprived[J]. Frontiers in Psychology,2019, 10: 1729. DOI:10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01729
37 Mou J, Shin D. Effects of social popularity and time scarcity on online consumer behaviour regarding smart healthcare products: An eye-tracking approach[J]. Computers in Human Behavior,2018, 78: 74-89. DOI:10.1016/j.chb.2017.08.049
38 Mullainathan S, Shafir E. Scarcity: Why having too little means so much[M]. New York: Times Books, 2013.
39 Netchaeva E, Rees M. Strategically stunning: The professional motivations behind the lipstick effect[J]. Psychological Science,2016, 27(8): 1157-1168. DOI:10.1177/0956797616654677
41 Park H, Lalwani A K, Silvera D H. The impact of resource scarcity on price-quality judgments[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2020, 46(6): 1110-1124. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucz031
42 Prediger S, Vollan B, Herrmann B. Resource scarcity and antisocial behavior[J]. Journal of Public Economics,2014, 119: 1-9. DOI:10.1016/j.jpubeco.2014.07.007
43 Rao A R. The quality of price as a quality cue[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2005, 42(4): 401-405. DOI:10.1509/jmkr.2005.42.4.401
44 Radel R, Clément-Guillotin C. Evidence of motivational influences in early visual perception: Hunger modulates conscious access[J]. Psychological Science,2012, 23(3): 232-234. DOI:10.1177/0956797611427920
45 Rosa J A, Geiger-Oneto S, Fajardo A B. Hope and innovativeness: Transformative factors for subsistence consumer-merchants[A]. Mick D G. Transformative consumer research for personal and collective well-being[M]. New York: Routledge, 2012.
47 Russell S A. Hunger: An unnatural history[M]. New York, NY: Basic Books, 2005.
48 Salerno A, Escoe B. Resource scarcity increases the value of pride[J]. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research,2020, 5(4): 458-469. DOI:10.1086/709891
49 Shah A K, Mullainathan S, Shafir E. Some consequences of having too little[J]. Science,2012, 338(6107): 682-685. DOI:10.1126/science.1222426
50 Shah A K, Shafir E, Mullainathan S. Scarcity frames value[J]. Psychological Science,2015, 26(4): 402-412. DOI:10.1177/0956797614563958
51 Shah A K, Zhao J Y, Mullainathan S, et al. Money in the mental lives of the poor[J]. Social Cognition,2018, 36(1): 4-19. DOI:10.1521/soco.2018.36.1.4
52 Sharma E, Alter A L. Financial deprivation prompts consumers to seek scarce goods[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2012, 39(3): 545-560. DOI:10.1086/664038
53 Spiller S A. Opportunity cost consideration[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2011, 38(4): 595-610. DOI:10.1086/660045
54 Sverke M, Hellgren J. The nature of job insecurity: Understanding employment uncertainty on the brink of a new millennium[J]. Applied Psychology,2002, 51(1): 23-42. DOI:10.1111/1464-0597.0077z
55 Tomm B M, Zhao J Y. Scarcity captures attention and induces neglect: Eyetracking and behavioral evidence[A]. Proceedings of the 38th annual conference of the cognitive science society[C]. Philadelphia: Cognitive Science Society, 2016.
56 Tully S M, Hershfield H E, Meyvis T. Seeking lasting enjoyment with limited money: Financial constraints increase preference for material goods over experiences[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2015, 42(1): 59-75. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucv007
57 Van Kerckhove A, Lunardo R, Fitzsimons G J. Monetary scarcity leads to increased desire for assortment[J]. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research,2020, 5(4): 377-390. DOI:10.1086/709889