开放式知识披露:研究综述与展望
Open Knowledge Disclosure: A Review and Prospects
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220622.402
[1]刘梓毓,杜玉申.开放式知识披露:研究综述与展望[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2023,45(04):104-118[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220622.402.
摘要
越来越多的以利润为导向的企业正在通过学术期刊与会议报告无偿地披露创新成果,这种被称作是“开放式知识披露”的现象引发了学者们的广泛兴趣。本文通过CiteSpace文献计量分析法与传统的文献回顾法系统地梳理了开放式知识披露的研究现状。在此基础上,本文辨析了开放式知识披露的相关概念,分析了开放式知识披露的驱动因素(企业内部因素与外部环境因素),阐述了开放式知识披露的主要渠道(期刊论文与学术会议),剖析了开放式知识披露的经济效果(基于创新获利理论和信号理论的研究)。本文认为,未来研究应关注开放式知识披露的新兴渠道,推动开放式知识披露理论体系的完善,分析开放式知识披露与其它独占策略的协同作用,重视中国情境下的开放式知识披露实践。从理论上看,本文丰富了创新获利理论与信号理论,为未来研究提供了潜在的研究方向。从实践上看,本文分析了开放式知识披露作为一种独占策略的可行性,为企业管理人员提供了有价值的决策参考。
Traditional innovation economics holds that the free disclosure of innovation achievements by enterprises is a kind of irrational behavior because it dramatically weakens the excess profits brought by knowledge monopoly and puts enterprises in a disadvantageous position in competition. Counterintuitively, more and more profit-oriented enterprises are disclosing their innovation achievements free of charge. This phenomenon called “open knowledge disclosure” has aroused the widespread interest of scholars.
Based on the CiteSpace bibliometric analysis, this paper summarizes the relevant concepts, driving factors, usual channels and economic effects of open knowledge disclosure. The conclusions include that: First, open knowledge disclosure has the characteristics of voluntary, free and open, significantly different from the connotation of knowledge spillover, knowledge sharing and open science. Second, the driving factors of open knowledge disclosure include internal and external factors. The former includes basic characteristics, R&D characteristics and strategic objectives, and the latter includes macro-environmental characteristics, industry characteristics and collaborative R&D relationships. Third, the usual channels of open knowledge disclosure include academic journals and conference proceedings. Existing research sometimes regards open source software and some particular patents as the channels of open knowledge disclosure. Fourth, this paper divides the economic effect of open knowledge disclosure into two categories: research from the perspective of PFI theory and research from the perspective of signaling theory. The former holds that open knowledge disclosure can prevent competitors from obtaining patents, promote product demand, achieve compatibility with complementary products, and affect technical standards, while the latter believes that enterprises can accumulate technical reputation, acquire external knowledge, and cultivate industrial environments through open knowledge disclosure.
This paper proposes the following prospects: First, future research should focus on emerging open knowledge disclosure channels such as the Internet and patents, and explore their differences and connections with traditional channels such as academic papers in terms of driving factors and economic effect, so as to expand the scope of research and solve cutting-edge problems. Second, empirical research based on promoting the perfection of the theoretical system of open knowledge disclosure should become the primary paradigm of future research. Third, future research should analyze the synergy between open knowledge disclosure and other appropriation strategies, guiding enterprises to obtain innovation profits more efficiently while expanding the theoretical depth. Fourth, future research should pay attention to open knowledge disclosure in China to provide more practical decision-making references for enterprise managers and expand the theoretical horizon.
关键词: 开放式知识披露,独占策略,创新管理,创新获利理论,信号理论