AI算法决策能提高员工的程序公平感知吗?
Can AI Algorithmic Decision-making Improve Employees’ Perception of Procedural Fairness?
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210818.103
[1]裴嘉良,刘善仕,钟楚燕,谌一璠.AI算法决策能提高员工的程序公平感知吗?[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2021,43(11):41-55[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210818.103.
摘要
人力资源决策程序的公平性始终是组织管理的一个关键问题。在数智化时代,越来越多的管理者期望引入人工智能算法优化决策环境并提高决策效率。但是,考虑到人力资源决策的直接对象是员工,他们如何感受、认知和评价人工智能算法决策程序公平性的问题十分重要。本文基于信息透明度的视角,以程序公平理论为研究框架,探究了人力资源决策中不同决策主体(人工智能算法vs.上级主管)对员工程序公平感知的影响机理。两个情境实验结果如下:实验1发现,在组织人力资源决策情境下,与上级主管决策相比,员工认为人工智能算法决策的信息透明度更低,并由此对人工智能算法决策产生更低的程序公平感知;实验2发现,组织包容型氛围在人工智能算法决策对员工程序公平感知的主效应中起调节作用,即当员工感知到具有较低水平的包容型氛围时,人工智能算法决策对程序公平感知的影响更加明显。本研究识别出人工智能算法决策潜在的负面影响,对于辩证地认识组织决策中人工智能的应用具有理论意义和实践价值。
With the development of digital technologies such as big data, artificial intelligence and machine learning, many organizations try to introduce AI algorithms into the decision-making process to avoid the subjective inherent biases. Although AI algorithms improve the scientificity of decision-making, they also raise the issue of fairness in the decision-making process. Considering that employees are the direct subject of HR decision-making, how employees view and evaluate the fairness of AI algorithmic decision-making process is very important. However, researches on the above questions are rather limited.
Based on the procedural fairness theory, this study discusses the impact of different decision-making subjects (AI algorithms vs. supervisors) on employees’ perception of fairness in the HR decision-making process. Through two experiments, we find that: (1) The decision-making of AI algorithms makes employees have a lower perception of procedural fairness than that of supervisors. (2) Information transparency mediates the relationship between AI algorithmic decision-making and employees’ perception of procedural fairness. Employees believe that AI algorithmic decision-making has lower information transparency, which in turn produces a lower perception of procedural fairness. (3) Inclusive climate moderates the relationship between AI algorithmic decision-making and employees’ perception of procedural fairness. When employees perceive a high level of organizational inclusive climate, the effect of AI algorithmic decision-making on the perception of program fairness will be weakened.
Overall, this study responds to the call for more research that bridges AI algorithmic decision-making and individual perception of procedural fairness by examining information transparency as a mediator and inclusive climate as a moderator in this relationship. The findings not only challenge the existing mainstream view that AI algorithmic decision-making does not exist a lower bias than human decision-making, but also offer useful advice to managers and provide implications for organizational HR decision-making practices in the digital and intelligent era.
关键词: 人工智能,算法,人力资源决策,信息透明度,程序公平