团队成员地位动态变化研究述评与展望
A Review on the Dynamic Change of Team Members’ Status
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2019.08.005
[1]刘德鹏,郑雅琴,贾良定,赵广军.团队成员地位动态变化研究述评与展望[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2019,41(08):58-72[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2019.08.005.
摘要
在工作场所中所处的地位是团队成员普遍关心的问题。目前的研究大多将地位视为静止和稳定的状态,而忽略了地位并不是一成不变的,而是处于不断获得、保持以及丢失的动态变化过程中。因此,深入了解团队成员的地位动态变化,不仅有利于全面理解工作场所地位现象,而且会对静态的地位研究形成补充和拓展。鉴于此,近年来工作场所地位动态变化方面的研究成为学者们关注的新兴领域。学者们从地位动态变化的机制、前导因素以及产生的影响等多个方面对该领域展开了分析。本文系统梳理了相关研究,具体阐释了团队成员地位的定义和分类;介绍了地位的自我增强机制;从情境被动论、情境互动论和情境决定论三个视角出发,归纳了地位获得的过程、原因以及前导因素,并对地位丢失带来的影响及其内在机理进行了回顾;在此基础上明确了地位动态变化方面研究尚需解决的问题和未来的研究方向。
Status is the basic reality that team members face in the workplace. The view that status is one of the basic needs of human beings has also been universally recognized by scholars. Previous studies on status mostly regard status as a static and stable phenomenon to explore the impact of different team members’ status differences. However, status is not unchanged, but in the process of continuous acquisition, maintenance and loss of change. Scholars have expanded this field from the causes, antecedents and impacts of changes in status. However, there is still a lack of comprehensive literature to summarize the existing research and point out the direction for future research. Therefore, this paper firstly defines team membership and distinguishes it from other similar concepts such as power, reputation, influence, etc. Status is the degree to which a person is respected, worshipped and voluntarily complied with by others because of his perceived instrumental social value. Secondly, this paper reviews the existing literature on the static research of team members’ status, and holds that the static research of team members’ status mainly focuses on two topics: identifying the advantages brought by high status of team members and exploring the internal mechanism of maintaining stable status. Thirdly, this paper focuses on the dynamic change of team members’ status. The dynamic change of team members’ status mainly focuses on the related research of team members’ status acquisition and status loss. Status acquisition refers to the promotion of team members’ status in the team; status loss refers to the reduction of their status in the team. The dynamic change of status mainly involves the interaction of individuals, other team members and situations. At present, most studies neglect the role of context and only discuss the interaction between individuals and other members of the team, which is a major drawback of current research. According to the way of setting the situation, we divide the current research on the dynamic change of status into three aspects: the passive perspective, the interactive perspective and the situational decision perspective. The passive perspective is also called the functional perspective, which emphasizes the subjective initiative of the individual and regards the situation as given and passive. The interactive perspective emphasizes the interaction between individual subjective factors and situations, breaking through the hypothesis that the team is task-oriented, and takes overall performance as the main goal. The situational decision perspective emphasizes the influence of environment itself and its sudden change of the active selection effect on status acquisition and loss. From this perspective, the situation is in the active actor position, while the individual is the passive acceptance role. Based on the above three research perspectives, this paper summarizes the relevant research on the acquisition and loss of existing status, and obtains an integrated theoretical framework. In addition, this paper also describes the dynamic process of status change (the process of status acquisition and the process of status loss) from three perspectives. At the same time, this paper also elaborates the antecedent variables and influence results of team members’ status. Finally, this paper summarizes the shortcomings of the existing research and points out future research directions.
关键词: 地位动态变化,地位获得,地位丢失