企业人力资源管理实践与工会实践的耦合构念和维度研究

The Construct and Dimensions of the Coupling of Enterprise HRMPs and Labor Union Practices

周潇,胡恩华,单红梅

2021 第 43 卷 第 07 期 页码 68-85

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210226.302

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

随着中国基层工会改革的推进,工会在企业组织中正发挥越来越积极的作用,特别是在当前员工的工作压力增大、企业劳资冲突日益多发的情况下,工会在改善员工情绪和行为以及企业劳动关系氛围等方面的作用越来越受到关注。与西方国家工会直接代表员工的“政府—企业—员工(工会)”产业关系三方模型不同,中国的产业关系遵循“政府—企业—员工—工会”四方模型,工会同时兼顾和协调企业和员工的利益,这就使得企业的人力资源管理实践和工会实践既相互制约又共同合作,形成相互影响、相互依赖的耦合关系,并能实现单个主体难以实现的结果。本文遵循构念领域说明的规范程序,先对二者耦合关系的现象重要性和定义进行了详细阐述,然后运用扎根理论的定性研究方法识别了二者耦合关系的相互认同、协同配合、监督约束三个构成维度。本文对于深入理解中国企业人力资源管理实践与工会实践之间的独特关系,以及更好地协调和发挥二者的功能,进而维护员工利益和促进企业发展,均具有积极意义。

With the reform of labor unions at the grassroots level in China, labor unions are exerting an increasingly positive influence on enterprises. In particular, under the current situation of increasing work pressure of employees and more labor disputes in enterprises, the roles of labor unions in improving employees’ emotions and behaviors and enterprises’ labor relations have attracted more and more attention. Unlike the tripartite industrial relationship model of “government-enterprise-employee (union)” in Western countries represented by the United States in which labor unions directly represent employees’ interests, the industrial relationship in China is characterized by a four-party model of “government-enterprise-employee-union” in which enterprise labor unions try to coordinate the interests of enterprises and employees. Under this circumstance, human resource management practices (HRMPs) and labor union practices restrict one another and cooperate with each other, forming a coupling relationship of mutual influence and interdependence, and achieve results that are difficult to be achieved by a single subject. However, theoretical research on this phenomenon lags behind management practices.

Following the procedure of construct domain specification, this study first explores the importance of the phenomenon and the conceptual definition of the construct of the coupling relationship, and then uses the qualitative research method of the grounded theory to identify the three components of the coupling relationship: mutual recognition, coordination and supervision. Specifically, the coupling relationship has the foundation of mutual recognition with the institutional guarantee of government laws and regulations, as well as the interdependence of HRMPs and labor union practices. The coupling relationship also has a wide range of agendas for coordination, integrating resources in many aspects such as managing labor relations, developing employee care, promoting corporate culture, improving employee participation, enhancing employee capabilities, and facilitating corporate innovation. Besides, the coupling relationship has the unique value of correcting each other and achieving sustainability through mutual supervision between the two, such as the participation of labor unions in the formulation of human resource management policies, the supervision of labor unions on human resource management to protect employees’ legal rights and fulfill contract obligations, and joint participation in collective negotiation.

This study makes several main contributions: First, it explores the construct of the coupling of HRMPs and labor union practices in Chinese enterprises, promoting indigenous studies on the relationship between the two types of practices. Second, it initially reveals the contents of the coupling relationship including mutual recognition, coordination and supervision, thus providing new insights for enterprises to improve HRMPs with the help of labor union practices, and offering guidance to improve operational efficiency for grassroots labor unions. Third, it promotes the integration of knowledge in the field of human resource management and industrial relations research, which is conducive to understanding and resolving labor conflicts. This provides practical implications for Chinese enterprises to build harmonious labor relations, thereby to safeguard employees’ interests and promote enterprises’ development simultaneously.

参考文献

3 陈维政, 任晗, 朱玖华, 等. 中国企业工会角色冲突对工会职能作用发挥的影响和对策研究[J]. 管理学报,2016, 13(3): 315-324. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2016.03.001
5 胡恩华, 胡京京, 单红梅, 等. 基于工会实践调节效应的高绩效工作系统归因对反生产行为的影响研究[J]. 管理学报,2020, 17(6): 833-842, 948. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2020.06.005
7 胡恩华, 章燕, 单红梅, 等. 企业承诺和工会承诺对员工建言行为的影响研究[J]. 管理学报,2018, 15(8): 1153-1160. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2018.08.007
9 李文贵. 工会、产权保护与民营企业研发投资[J]. 科学学研究,2014, 32(3): 374-383. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1003-2053.2014.03.008
11 孙中伟, 姚慧. 企业工会如何促进产业转型升级[J]. 学术研究,2020, (1): 103-109. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-7326.2020.01.014
13 吴清军. 中国劳动关系学40年(1978—2018)[M]. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 2018.
14 于桂兰, 梁潇杰, 孙瑜. 基于扎根理论的企业和谐劳动关系质性研究[J]. 管理学报,2016, 13(10): 1446-1455, 1533. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2016.10.003
19 Cooke F L. Chinese industrial relations research: In search of a broader analytical framework and representation[J]. Asia Pacific Journal of Management,2014, 31(3): 875-898. DOI:10.1007/s10490-014-9386-8
20 Dunlop J T. Industrial relations, labor economics, and policy decisions[J]. Challenge,1977, 20(2): 6-12. DOI:10.1080/05775132.1977.11470310
22 Hernaus T, Pavlovic D, Klindzic M. Organizational career management practices: The role of the relationship between HRM and trade unions[J]. Employee Relations,2019, 41(1): 84-100. DOI:10.1108/ER-02-2018-0035
23 Jia L D, You S Y, Du Y Z. Chinese context and theoretical contributions to management and organization research: A three-decade review[J]. Management and Organization Review,2012, 8(1): 173-209. DOI:10.1111/j.1740-8784.2011.00282.x
25 Lewis B R, Templeton G F, Byrd T A. A methodology for construct development in MIS research[J]. European Journal of Information Systems,2005, 14(4): 388-400. DOI:10.1057/palgrave.ejis.3000552
27 Liu F, Chow I H S, Zhu W C, et al. The paradoxical mechanisms of high-performance work systems (HPWSs) on perceived workload: A dual-path mediation model[J]. Human Resource Management Journal,2020, 30(2): 278-292. DOI:10.1111/1748-8583.12277
28 Liu W C, Guthrie J P, Flood P C, et al. Unions and the adoption of high performance work systems: Does employment security play a role?[J]. ILR Review,2009, 63(1): 109-127. DOI:10.1177/001979390906300106
30 Rubinstein S A, McCarthy J E. Union-management partnerships, teacher collaboration, and student performance[J]. ILR Review,2016, 69(5): 1114-1132. DOI:10.1177/0019793916660508
32 Tsui A S. Contextualization in Chinese management research[J]. Management and Organization Review,2006, 2(1): 1-13. DOI:10.1111/j.1740-8784.2006.00033.x
33 Whetten D A, Felin T, King B G. The practice of theory borrowing in organizational studies: Current issues and future directions[J]. Journal of Management,2009, 35(3): 537-563.