“扶大厦之将倾”:女性高管、危机企业反转与管理者认知
Female Executives, Organizational Turnaround and Managerial Cognition
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200312.301
[1]徐高彦,李桂芳,陶颜,刘洪.“扶大厦之将倾”:女性高管、危机企业反转与管理者认知[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2020,42(05):42-59[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200312.301.
摘要
现实中不少知名企业在遭遇危机时会聘任女性高管,出人意料的是相当数量的企业由此成功实现了反转,这一事实背后的逻辑引人深思。作为组织能力、战略选择与组织绩效间关系机理的底层逻辑,管理者认知是决定危机企业反转的重要因素。那么,女性高管是否在管理者认知方面具有独特性并在危机企业反转过程中起正向作用呢?本文选用沪深两市A股非金融类上市公司2005—2011年的数据,基于高阶梯队理论与管理者认知视角,构建了女性高管、专业能力与政治关联对危机企业反转的解释框架。在本研究的观测样本范围内,实证检验结果表明:(1)女性高管对危机企业反转呈现显著正向影响作用,高管中女性比例越高越有利于反转;且在排除行业特殊性和企业生命周期等因素的影响后,上述结论依旧成立。(2)专业能力、政治关联对女性高管与企业反转之间的关系起正向调节作用。本文反对附和“女性主义”来做“预设观点、政治正确”式研究,而是在高阶梯队理论和性别差异研究的进展之上,考虑“玻璃天花板”和“玻璃悬崖”效应,从管理者认知视角研究女性高管与危机企业反转的关系,为“雷曼姐妹假说”的验证做出了贡献,研究结论也为女性高管职位合法性提供了证据,对于企业通过高管团队建设稳定经营业绩具有启示意义。
In reality, many well-known companies hire female executives in crisis. Surprisingly, a considerable number of companies have turned around successfully. This phenomenon is thought-provoking. Managerial cognition constructs the underlying logic of the internal mechanism of organizational capabilities, strategic choice, and organizational performance, which plays a decisive role in the organizational turnaround. Therefore, based on a managerial cognition perspective, we raise a fascinating question: do female executives have unique characteristics in managerial cognition and play a decisive role in an organizational turnaround? With the sample of A-share non-financial companies listed in Shanghai and Shenzhen Exchanges from 1999 to 2012, this study constructs an interpretation framework of female executives, professional competence and political connections for the organizational turnaround. The results show that: (1) Female executives have a significantly positive impact on the organizational turnaround in crisis. There is a significantly positive relationship between the proportion of women and the organizational turnaround. Furthermore, after excluding the influence of industry and organizational life cycle, the above conclusion is still valid. (2) Professional competence and political connections of female executives reinforce the positive effect between female executives and the organizational turnaround. This study enriches the relevant research on the managerial cognition of female executives, verifies the “Lehman Sisters Hypothesis”, and has important implications for stabilizing organizational operation.
The contributions are as follows: First, it provides evidence for the legitimacy of female executive positions. Many companies still lack correct cognition and enough attention to the position legitimacy of “occupational minorities”, and there are also explicit or implicit “glass ceiling” and “glass cliff”. Under this background, this study argues that female executives are not “scapegoats” or “vases” in crisis enterprises. On the contrary, based on a managerial cognition perspective, they are more likely to be leaders who play cognitive advantages and help crisis enterprises to turn around. This study suggests that organizations should re-examine the legality of female executive positions. Second, it provides a new perspective on the turnaround strategy of crisis enterprises. Previous studies have emphasized the impact of environment, resource capability, retrenchment, and strategic actions to promote the turnaround based on the Industrial Organization Theory, Transaction Cost Theory, Resource-based View and so on. However, few studies have illustrated the importance of managerial cognition. Therefore, based on the characteristics of female executives, it is of great value to explore the impact of the human spiritual model and cognitive framework on the strategic effectiveness of crisis enterprises. Third, it expands the research on the causal factors of organizational turnaround. Based on the Upper Echelons Theory, the turnaround outcomes of crisis enterprises are significantly influenced by the top management team compensation, executive turnover, CEO status and so on. This study further introduces the new progress of the research on the TMT Heterogeneity, and it includes the proportion of female executives, professional competence and political connections into research, which enriches the research on the driving factors of organizational turnaround.
关键词: 女性高管,企业反转,管理者认知,专业能力,政治关联