多个大股东与审计定价——基于中国家族企业的研究

Multiple Large Shareholders and Audit Pricing: Evidence from Chinese Family Companies

牛瑞阳,陈琳,李瑞涛,谢光华

2021 第 43 卷 第 06 期 页码 57-73

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210315.202

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

在传统公司治理环境中,普遍存在的多个大股东所有权现象,是上市公司重要的监督制衡结构。本文在家族企业多个大股东之间存在典型裙带关系的特定情境下,从审计定价视角考察监督或制衡机制是否有效。基于2007—2017年沪深A股家族上市公司数据,本文对家族企业中多个大股东的互动如何影响审计定价展开研究,发现拥有多个大股东的家族企业审计收费显著更高。进一步研究发现,家族企业多个大股东与审计收费之间的显著正相关关系主要存在于控股股东发生股权质押时以及市场化程度低的地区,并且在市场化程度低的地区,股权质押会显著增强多个大股东对审计费用的提升作用。机制检验表明,盈余管理、送转股和股票策略性改名三种市值管理手段,是多个大股东影响审计定价的具体路径。研究结果从审计定价角度揭示了家族企业多个大股东的合谋动机,为多个大股东经济后果的文献提供了新“拼图”,也为理解资本市场侵占中小股东利益事件中的审计失职现象提供了经验证据。

Multiple large shareholders (MLS) are a general ownership phenomenon in the global capital market. In the traditional context of corporate governance, non-controlling large shareholders are the key guardians of the interests of small and medium shareholders. They can not only supervise the controlling shareholders, but also enhance the value of companies. However, in recent years, the events that MLS of family companies unite to infringe the interests of small and medium investors are increasing. Therefore, in the special case of the typical nepotism of MLS in family companies, it is worth further testing whether the supervision and balance function of large shareholders still exists. Audit pricing has always been the focus of the audit theory and practice. The principal-agent problem between internal large shareholders and external investors has a crucial impact on audit pricing. Audit pricing also provides a good external perspective for us to explore whether there is any collusion motivation between large shareholders of family companies or not. Under the special circumstances of typical nepotism among the major shareholders of family companies, this paper examines whether the supervision and balance function of MLS still exists from the perspective of audit pricing. Based on the data of Shanghai and Shenzhen A-share family listed companies from 2007 to 2017, we find that the existence of MLS stimulates a significant increase in audit fees. This phenomenon exists only when the controlling shareholders of family companies pledge their shares and the market is undeveloped. Moreover, the equity pledge will significantly enhance the promotion effect of MLS on audit fees in undeveloped areas. The channel effect test shows that MLS stimulates the stock price through earnings management, stock dividends and strategic stock change. These three ways can lead to the increase of audit risk and auditing institutions always choose to charge a premium to compensate the risk. This paper scrutinizes the possible collusion motivation of MLS in family companies from the perspective of audit pricing, which provides a new “puzzle” for the research of economic consequences of MLS. It also provides some empirical evidence for understanding auditors’ dereliction of duty regarding the encroachment on the interests of small and medium shareholders in the capital market. And through the research of whether MLS in family companies contribute to higher audit fees, this paper also provides a supplement for the risk compensation theory of the audit pricing theory. The policy suggestions of this paper are mainly reflected as follows: (1) As for the collusion among MLS in family companies, investors should strengthen the relevant protection consciousness. (2) In China’s capital market, there are so many accidents that large shareholders of family companies empty the wealth of small shareholders. The external independent auditor is indeed responsible for dereliction of duty. The research has certain enlightenment for the regulatory authorities to regulate the professional ethics of auditing institutions and protect the interests of external investors.

参考文献

2 姜付秀, 蔡欣妮, 朱冰. 多个大股东与股价崩盘风险[J]. 会计研究,2018, (1): 68-74. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1003-2886.2018.01.011
5 刘颖斐, 张小虎. 企业诉讼风险与审计收费——基于关键审计事项披露视角[J]. 审计与经济研究,2019, 34(6): 33-45. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1004-4833.2019.06.004
11 张俊瑞, 余思佳, 程子健. 大股东股权质押会影响审计师决策吗?——基于审计费用与审计意见的证据[J]. 审计研究,2017, (3): 65-73. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-4239.2017.03.010
12 张友棠, 熊毅, 曾芝红. 异常审计收费与分类转移盈余管理——经济租金还是审计成本[J]. 审计研究,2019, (2): 82-90. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-4239.2019.02.013
14 Adelopo I, Jallow K, Scott P. Multiple large ownership structure, audit committee activity and audit fees: Evidence from the UK[J]. Journal of Applied Accounting Research,2012, 13(2): 100-121. DOI:10.1108/09675421211254821
15 Attig N, El Ghoul S, Guedhami O. Do multiple large shareholders play a corporate governance role? Evidence from East Asia[J]. The Journal of Financial Research,2009, 32(4): 395-422. DOI:10.1111/j.1475-6803.2009.01255.x
16 Attig N, Guedhami O, Mishra D. Multiple large shareholders, control contests, and implied cost of equity[J]. Journal of Corporate Finance,2008, 14(5): 721-737. DOI:10.1016/j.jcorpfin.2008.08.008
17 Bosch J C, Hirschey M. The valuation effects of corporate name changes[J]. Financial Management,1989, 18(4): 64-73. DOI:10.2307/3665798
18 Cai C X, Hillier D, Wang J. The cost of multiple large shareholders[J]. Financial Management,2016, 45(2): 401-430. DOI:10.1111/fima.12090
19 DeFond M, Zhang J. A review of archival auditing research[J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics,2014, 58(2-3): 275-326. DOI:10.1016/j.jacceco.2014.09.002
20 Edmans A, Holderness C G. Blockholders: A survey of theory and evidence[A]. Hermalin B E, Weisbach M S. The handbook of the economics of corporate governance[M]. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2017.
21 Faccio M, Long L H P, Young L. Dividends and expropriation[J]. American Economic Review,2001, 91(1): 54-78. DOI:10.1257/aer.91.1.54
22 Fang Y L, Hu M, Yang Q S. Do executives benefit from shareholder disputes? Evidence from multiple large shareholders in Chinese listed firms[J]. Journal of Corporate Finance,2018, 51: 275-315. DOI:10.1016/j.jcorpfin.2018.06.008
23 Griffin D, Tversky A. The weighing of evidence and the determinants of confidence[J]. Cognitive Psychology,1992, 24(3): 411-435. DOI:10.1016/0010-0285(92)90013-R
25 Jiang F X, Cai W J, Wang X. Multiple large shareholders and corporate investment: Evidence from China[J]. Journal of Corporate Finance,2018, 50: 66-83. DOI:10.1016/j.jcorpfin.2018.02.001
26 Kot H W. Corporate name changes: Price reactions and long-run performance[J]. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,2011, 19(2): 230-244. DOI:10.1016/j.pacfin.2010.10.003
27 Mishra D R. Multiple large shareholders and corporate risk taking: Evidence from East Asia[J]. Corporate Governance: An International Review,2011, 19(6): 507-528. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-8683.2011.00862.x
28 Pindado J, Requejo I, de la Torre C. Do family firms use dividend policy as a governance mechanism? Evidence from the Euro zone[J]. Corporate Governance: An International Review,2012, 20(5): 413-431. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-8683.2012.00921.x
29 Sauerwald S, Peng M W. Informal institutions, shareholder coalitions, and principal–principal conflicts[J]. Asia Pacific Journal of Management,2013, 30(3): 853-870. DOI:10.1007/s10490-012-9312-x
30 Simunic D A. The pricing of audit services: Theory and evidence[J]. Journal of Accounting Research,1980, 18(1): 161-190. DOI:10.2307/2490397
31 Tadelis S. What’s in a name? Reputation as a tradeable asset[J]. American Economic Review,1999, 89(3): 548-563. DOI:10.1257/aer.89.3.548