政策与文化因素组态效应对企业创新的影响——一项基于fsQCA方法的研究
Impact of Political and Cultural Configuration on Enterprises’ Innovation: A Study Based on fsQCA Approach
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200821.401
[1]石声萍,何新月,杨刚,洪静,王双龙.政策与文化因素组态效应对企业创新的影响——一项基于fsQCA方法的研究[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2020,42(12):89-103[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200821.401.
摘要
本文以重庆、江苏的42家企业为案例样本,基于组织文化视角,结合中国制度转型背景下的政策环境特性,应用组态思维和模糊集定性比较分析方法整合了政策环境层面与组织文化层面的6个前因条件,探讨了影响企业创新的多重并发因素与因果复杂机制。研究发现:(1)单一的政策环境因素或组织创新文化因素无法有效激励企业创新,需要在相互间的联动匹配中共同影响创新绩效。(2)政策环境和组织创新文化相交互的创新模式是企业实现创新激励的最佳选择,并存在2类产生高创新绩效的创新模式,即价值观主导型和内外协同型。其中,内外协同型相较价值观主导型在企业创新绩效的提升上发挥着更加重要的作用。(3)产生非高创新绩效的模式有1类,且与导致高创新绩效的2类创新模式并非相互对立。研究结论拓展了政策环境与组织文化匹配的创新视角,有助于深入理解创新激励机制,为企业有效激励创新提供理论参考和有益启示。
This study starts from the perspective of organizational culture and combines the characteristics of the policy environment based on the background of China’s institutional transition. First, it integrates the external policy factors for enterprises with the internal innovation culture factors to build an integrated analysis framework to understand the differences in enterprise innovation performance. Second, 42 enterprises in Chongqing City and Jiangsu Province are analyzed by using configuration thinking and fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis, while the multiple concurrent factors and causal complex mechanisms affecting enterprise innovation are discussed. The results are as follows: (1) Single policy environment factor or organizational innovation culture factor cannot effectively stimulate enterprise innovation, so it is necessary to jointly influence innovation performance in interactive matching. (2) The innovation model with the interaction between the policy environment and the organizational innovation culture is the best choice for enterprises to achieve innovation incentives, and there are two types of innovation models that produce high innovation performance, namely the value-oriented model and the internal and external collaborative model. Among them, the internal and external collaborative model plays a more important role in the improvement of enterprise innovation performance than the other. (3) There is one type of model that produces non-high innovative performance, and it is not in opposition to the two types of innovation models that produce highly innovative performance. In other words, the non-high innovative performance model cannot be used to derive the reasons for high innovation performance in a reverse way. This study contributes to the extant literature in three aspects: First of all, the conclusion expands the innovation perspective of the policy environment and organizational culture matching, opens the “black box” of the process of policy incentive transmission to the organization, helps to solve the dilemma of failure of innovation policy incentive from the micro-level, and also enriches the discovery of organizational culture theory at the environmental level. Secondly, from the perspective of configuration, various modes to improve innovation performance are found, as well as the interdependence among various antecedent conditions. Finally, the asymmetry between configuration and condition enhances the explanatory power of innovation phenomenon, and makes up for the defect of the extant literature that cannot be applied to the explanation of innovation failure. Generally speaking, while revealing the linkage and matching relationships between policy conditions and organizational innovation culture on the circumstance of China’s economical transitions, it not only helps researchers to fully understand the interdependence and causal complexity of enterprise innovation, but also provides ideas and solutions for managers to effectively use internal and external resources to stimulate innovation.
关键词: 政策环境,组织创新文化,创新绩效,组态效应,fsQCA方法