绩效身份:概念辨析、研究框架与未来展望

Performance-based Identity: Connotative Features, Research Framework and Prospects

徐钊,席酉民,胥思齐,梁朝高

2022 第 44 卷 第 07 期 页码 82-100

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220115.201

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

绩效身份指在成就相关的场景中,个体赋予个人意义的、关于自己是何种类型绩效表现者的自我知识,即以特定类型的绩效表现为参考的自我定义方式。绩效有不同等级,但现有研究认为很少存在低绩效身份,这与本土实践观察不符。此外,由于绩效身份研究比较前沿,目前尚缺乏开展研究的系统性框架。对此,本文首先在社会认同理论指导下,兼顾本土管理实践,通过分析绩效身份的形成过程提出其概念本质,明确了本土低绩效身份的存在性和重要性。其次,整合社会认同理论主导下的组织中个体身份研究的重点和绩效身份的独特性,提出绩效身份研究的一般逻辑,继而结合相关话题的研究和对管理现象的初步观察对其进行充实,本文最终搭建了包含多层次前因、机制和结果的绩效身份研究框架。最后,根据上述框架,立足于我国独特国情,本文提出未来研究的初步方向。本文对绩效身份内涵的厘清以及所搭建的初步研究框架为未来研究奠定了必要的基础。

In organizations, it is becoming common for employees to define themselves based on the level of their performance. Western scholars have conceptualized it as the performance-based identity, that is, knowledge about oneself as a particular type of performer in a certain achievement setting, together with the personal meanings this self-knowledge holds for the person. The phenomenon of performance-based identity not only challenges the effectiveness of traditional incentives, but also provides a new way of explaining practices by self-recognition shaped by performance. However, the existing research on performance-based identity is based on a specific western organizational background, ignoring the existence of low-performance-based identity and lacking a systematic research framework to guide research. Therefore, this paper aims to introduce performance-based identity into the field of indigenous management research through the localization of the concept of performance-based identity and the establishment of a systematic research framework.

In this regard, based on the basic assumptions of social identity theory on identity construction and guided by the strict definition of performance-based identity, this paper firstly analyzes the performance-based identity phenomenon within indigenous management practices from the perspective of “specific performance level satisfying certain basic motivation of identification”, putting forward the existence and importance of indigenous low-performance-based identity. This paper then proposes a general research logic for performance-based identity based on the integration of social identity theory literature on individual identity and the special characteristics of performance-based identity. On this basis, combined with related topic research and preliminary observations of management phenomena, this paper constructs a performance-based identity research framework from multiple aspects of antecedents, mechanisms and results. Finally, according to the framework, this paper proposes preliminary directions for future research based on the unique Chinese context.

This paper finds that: First, performance-based identity is essentially a kind of self-definition according to performance ranking driven by self-enhancement and uncertainty reduction motivations. The existence of performance-based identity phenomenon does not depend on the level of performance ranking. Second, future research needs to take into account performance-based identity led by different motivations, focusing on their dynamic and static antecedents, their reinforcement, multi-identity networking and threat response mechanisms, as well as their impact on consequences like individual performance, mental health, and organizational behavior.

The theoretical value of this paper is that: First, through confirming the existence and explanatory power of low-performance-based identity, it makes up for the lack of one-sided attention to high-performance-based identity in existing Western background research, helping to conduct full-spectrum extended research of performance-based identity under a rigorous and consistent conceptual consensus. Second, through the establishing of multi-level research framework of performance-based identity, it provides a systematic entry point involving rich topics for the future research of performance-based identity, introducing and promoting the development of research on performance-based identity in the indigenous management field. Regarding management practices, this paper calls on individuals to make good use of their own performance-based identity while not being confined to the single performance-based identity, inspires organization managers to avoid adopting an extremely individualistic performance evaluation system and arrange different types of performers according to work characteristics, and proposes that the development of multi-achievement value could improve group welfare at the social level.

参考文献

1 Alessandri G, Cortina J M, Sheng Z, et al. Where you came from and where you are going: The role of performance trajectory in promotion decisions[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2021, 106(4): 599-623. DOI:10.1037/apl0000696
2 Ashforth B E, Harrison S H, Corley K G. Identification in organizations: An examination of four fundamental questions[J]. Journal of Management,2008, 34(3): 325-374. DOI:10.1177/0149206308316059
3 Ashforth B E, Schinoff B S. Identity under construction: How individuals come to define themselves in organizations[J]. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior,2016, 3: 111-137. DOI:10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-041015-062322
4 Downes P E, Crawford E R, Seibert S E, et al. Referents or role models? The self-efficacy and job performance effects of perceiving higher performing peers[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2021, 106(3): 422-438. DOI:10.1037/apl0000519
5 Ganco M, Ziedonis R H, Agarwal R. More stars stay, but the brightest ones still leave: Job hopping in the shadow of patent enforcement[J]. Strategic Management Journal,2015, 36(5): 659-685. DOI:10.1002/smj.2239
6 Hoyer P. To be, or not to be elite, that is the question: The unresolved identity struggles of ex-consultants[J]. Culture and Organization,2022, 28(1): 1-24. DOI:10.1080/14759551.2021.1957889
7 Miscenko D, Day D V. Identity and identification at work[J]. Organizational Psychology Review,2016, 6(3): 215-247. DOI:10.1177/2041386615584009
8 Nurmohamed S. The underdog effect: When low expectations increase performance[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2020, 63(4): 1106-1133. DOI:10.5465/amj.2017.0181
10 Piening E P, Salge T O, Antons D, et al. Standing together or falling apart? Understanding employees’ responses to organizational identity threats[J]. Academy of Management Review,2020, 45(2): 325-351. DOI:10.5465/amr.2016.0457
11 Ramarajan L. Past, present and future research on multiple identities: Toward an intrapersonal network approach[J]. Academy of Management Annals,2014, 8(1): 589-659. DOI:10.5465/19416520.2014.912379
12 Reynolds T, Zhu L, Aquino K, et al. Dual pathways to bias: Evaluators’ ideology and ressentiment independently predict racial discrimination in hiring contexts[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2021, 106(4): 624-641. DOI:10.1037/apl0000804
13 Vadera A K, Pratt M G. Love, hate, ambivalence, or indifference? A conceptual examination of workplace crimes and organizational identification[J]. Organization Science,2013, 24(1): 172-188. DOI:10.1287/orsc.1110.0714
14 Vough H C, Caza B B. Where do I go from here? Sensemaking and the construction of growth-based stories in the wake of denied promotions[J]. Academy of Management Review,2017, 42(1): 103-128. DOI:10.5465/amr.2013.0177
15 Walker B W, Caprar D V. When performance gets personal: Towards a theory of performance-based identity[J]. Human Relations,2020, 73(8): 1077-1105. DOI:10.1177/0018726719851835