投资者情绪与产业结构升级——“投融资途径”与“信号传递”的视角
Investor Sentiment and Industrial Structure Upgrading: Based on the Perspectives of “Investment and Financing Effect” and “Signal Effect”
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20190816.002
[1]李林波,刘维奇.投资者情绪与产业结构升级——“投融资途径”与“信号传递”的视角[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2020,42(02):111-123[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20190816.002.
摘要
本文从行为金融学的角度探讨了“金融支持实体经济”的影响机制,资本市场的投资者情绪能否促进战略性新兴产业发展,对对冲当前经济下行压力具有重要意义。本文构建了一个“纯净的”投资者情绪指标,使用2000—2016年中国股市上市公司数据、行业数据及宏观统计数据实证检验投资者情绪对产业结构升级的影响。研究表明:(1)资本市场的投资者情绪促进了产业扩张,影响渠道除“投融资效应”外还存在“信号效应”,投资者情绪可以调整经济资源配置,支持实体经济发展;(2)战略性新兴产业的投资者情绪高涨,吸引经济资源向新兴产业集聚,有更多更高质量的投资、从业人数、企业数量、产成品存货和总资产推动新兴产业快速发展。(3)无论在宏观层面还是微观层面,投资者情绪对产业结构升级的正效应依然稳健。本文丰富了“金融支持实体经济”的研究,有助于政府在产业政策制定和资本市场监管中统筹资本市场和产业发展的关系,实现产业结构升级。
In our main analyses, we use two hypotheses to examine the effect of investor sentiment on industrial upgrading. The first is the investment and financing hypothesis, which is synthesized by “equity financing approach” and “catering approach”. It is believed that the upsurge of industry sentiment promotes the financing and investment of listed companies, thereby promoting the industry to expand its production level. The second is the signal hypothesis. China’s stock market is inefficient in pricing and unreasonable in the system design. The high sentiment leads to the signal of “making rich” to economic participants, attracting capital, labor and other resources from the real economy into the industry. In this paper, we select the quarterly sample data of 3 027 listed companies and 78 industries in China from 2000 to 2016. All data come from the CSMAR database. We construct a “pure” industry sentiment(Sent), and We select closed-end fund discount, turnover, Beta, P/E and excess return for principal component analysis to get an investor sentiment proxy. Then, we use the “residual” method to further separate out the parts affected by industrial policies, macroeconomic cycles, and industrial development from the sentiment proxy to get the industry sentiment. This paper firstly uses OLS regression to find that investor sentiment promotes industry expansion. We build short-selling weight as a tool variable for 2SLS regression. Further, we use macro-statistical data and company data to the robustness test. The results show that for emerging industries, investor sentiment not only has a positive impact on investment and financing, but also promotes the labor quality. However, for traditional manufacturing industry, investor sentiment has no impact on industrial expansion. Investor sentiment promotes industrial expansion through “investment and financing effect” and “signal effect”. The latter finds that investor sentiment can attract economic resources to agglomerate in emerging industries, promote more and higher quality investment, employees, enterprise units, inventory of finished products and total assets in emerging industries, and promote the rapid development of emerging industries. Our government could promote emerging industries through the design of the capital market system. Capital market regulators reduce the irrational characteristics of interfering with investors. The contributions of this paper are as follows: Firstly, it shows that investor sentiment in the stock market is one of the factors influencing macro-economy, which further enriches the research literature on “financial support for real economy”. Secondly, it also finds a new channel — “signal effect”. The high sentiment towards the emerging industry promotes the investment of various elements in the industry. Thirdly, it effectively expands the extension of the investor sentiment theory, and shows its “good” effect in macro-economy, that is investor sentiment promotes the agglomeration of economic resources to emerging industries.
关键词: 投资者情绪,产业结构升级,产业政策,信号传递