悖论式领导:研究述评与展望

Paradoxical Leadership: A Literature Review and Prospects

谭乐,蒿坡,杨晓,宋合义

2020 第 42 卷 第 04 期 页码 63-79

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200306.101

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

悖论式领导是指领导者采用看似竞争却相互关联的领导行为,旨在同时满足工作中的竞争性需求。这种新型的领导行为是基于中国传统阴阳哲学理论提出的,它突破了权变视角下“二选一”(either-or)的局限性,转向“二者皆”(both-and),通过悖论思维发挥整合矛盾的协同效应。悖论式领导研究已取得了一些进展,但是缺少关于该主题的系统综述。本文通过介绍其概念起源、内涵和测量,进而梳理其前因、结果变量及其作用机制,对已有研究进行了系统的梳理和述评,构建了悖论式领导研究的整体框架并指出未来研究的方向。本文发现,已有研究大多聚焦于探讨东方情境下悖论式领导的作用效果,对其成因以及西方情境下的作用效果关注不足,且存在不一致的研究结论。因此,从概念和测量的完善、悖论思想对已有领导研究的拓展与整合、对悖论领导内在形成机制的挖掘、加强悖论式领导的西方情境及跨文化比较研究、进一步完善和丰富相关研究设计等方面对未来研究进行了展望。本文为深化东西方情境下悖论式领导的研究和实践提供了重要参考。

As contemporary organizations and their environments become increasingly complex, turbulent and uncertain, leaders will inevitably face more contradictory challenges and tensions. It becomes one of the key indicators of leadership effectiveness that how leaders integrate internal and external resources and manage contradictions and crises under complex and uncertain environments.

Combining Chinese Yin-Yang philosophy with Western leadership theory, scholars put forward the concept of paradoxical leadership. Paradoxical leadership describes the new leader behaviors that are seemingly competing, yet interrelated, to meet competing workplace demands simultaneously and over time. Rather than being “either-or” contingency-based action, paradoxical leadership reflects a “both-and” strategy that behaviorally accepts and integrates contradictory demands based on Chinese traditional philosophy of Yin-Yang. Using the “both-and” strategy, paradoxical leadership highlights the opportunities for effectively managing competing demands by acceptance and integration of contradictions, which has become one of the hot topics in leadership research.

The existing literature has made some progress, but there are few systematic review studies. The present paper systematically reviews previous studies on paradoxical leadership. Firstly, it introduces the concept origin, connotation and measurement of paradoxical leadership, and distinguishes paradoxical leadership from contingent leadership and ambidextrous leadership. Secondly, it systematically analyzes and summarizes the antecedents, outcome variables and influence mechanisms of paradoxical leadership based on previous empirical studies, and then constructs an integrated analysis framework. Thirdly, it points out the limitations of the existing research. We find that previous studies mostly focus on the effect of paradoxical leadership in the Eastern context, and pay little attention to its antecedents and effect in the Western context, and there are also some inconsistent conclusions. Finally, based on the shortcomings of the existing research, this paper puts forward some future research directions, including concept and measurement improvement, developing and integrating other combinations of leadership aspects by paradox lens, exploring how paradoxical leadership forms from the perspectives of sense-making and social culture, extending paradoxical leadership research in the Western context and cross-cultural studies, and using multiple research design.

The contributions of this paper are to clarify the latest progress of paradoxical leadership research, to provide the limitations of the existing research and possible future research directions, and to provide an important reference for promoting the research and practice of paradoxical leadership in the Eastern and Western contexts. The last but the most important is to make researchers and managers pay more attention to Chinese traditional philosophy thought in management research and practice.

参考文献

1 付正茂. 悖论式领导对双元创新能力的影响: 知识共享的中介作用[J]. 兰州财经大学学报,2017, (1): 11-20. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1004-5465.2017.01.002
4 刘善堂, 刘洪. 复杂环境中悖论式领导的应对能力研究[J]. 现代管理科学,2015, (10): 13-15. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1007-368X.2015.10.004
6 罗瑾琏, 花常花, 钟竞. 悖论式领导对知识团队创新的影响及作用机制研究[J]. 科技进步与对策,2015, (11): 121-125. DOI:10.6049/kjjbydc.2015010325
7 罗瑾琏, 赵莉, 韩杨, 等. 双元领导研究进展述评[J]. 管理学报,2016, (12): 1882-1889. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2016.12.018
8 庞大龙, 徐立国, 席酉民. 悖论管理的思想溯源、特征启示与未来前景[J]. 管理学报,2017, (2): 168-175. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2017.02.002
11 苏勇, 雷霆. 悖论式领导对员工创造力的影响: 基于工作激情的中介作用[J]. 技术经济,2018, (9): 10-17. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-980X.2018.09.002
16 Balkundi P, Harrison D A. Ties, leaders, and time in teams: Strong inference about network structure’s effects on team viability and performance[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2006, 49(1): 49-68. DOI:10.5465/amj.2006.20785500
17 Berson Y, Waldman D A, Pearce C L. Enhancing our understanding of vision in organizations: Toward an integration of leader and follower processes[J]. Organizational Psychology Review,2016, 6(2): 171-191. DOI:10.1177/2041386615583736
18 Fairhurst G T, Putnam L L. An integrative methodology for organizational oppositions: Aligning grounded theory and discourse analysis[J]. Organizational Research Methods,2019, 22(4): 917-940. DOI:10.1177/1094428118776771
19 Griffin M A, Neal A, Parker S K. A new model of work role performance: Positive behavior in uncertain and interdependent contexts[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2007, 50(2): 327-347. DOI:10.5465/amj.2007.24634438
20 Hiller N J, Sin H P, Ponnapalli A R, et al. Benevolence and authority as WEIRDly unfamiliar: A multi-language meta-analysis of paternalistic leadership behaviors from 152 studies[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2019, 30(1): 165-184. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2018.11.003
22 Kaiser R B, Craig S B. Building a better mouse Trap: Item characteristics associated with rating discrepancies in 360-degree feedback[J]. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research,2005, 57(4): 235-245. DOI:10.1037/1065-9293.57.4.235
23 Kauppila O P, Tempelaar M P. The social-cognitive underpinnings of employees’ ambidextrous behaviour and the supportive role of group managers’ leadership[J]. Journal of Management Studies,2016, 53(6): 1019-1044. DOI:10.1111/joms.12192
24 Lee A, Willis S, Tian A W. Empowering leadership: A meta-analytic examination of incremental contribution, mediation, and moderation[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2018, 39(3): 306-325. DOI:10.1002/job.2220
25 Lewis M W. Exploring paradox: Toward a more comprehensive guide[J]. Academy of Management Review,2000, 25(4): 760-776. DOI:10.5465/amr.2000.3707712
26 Lewis M W, Andriopoulos C, Smith W K. Paradoxical leadership to enable strategic agility[J]. California Management Review,2014, 56(3): 58-77. DOI:10.1525/cmr.2014.56.3.58
27 Li Q, She Z L, Yang B Y. Promoting innovative performance in multidisciplinary teams: The roles of paradoxical leadership and team perspective taking[J]. Frontiers in Psychology,2018, 9: 1083. DOI:10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01083
28 Mammassis C S, Schmid P C. The role of power asymmetry and paradoxical leadership in software development team agility[A]. Sund K, Galavan R, Brusoni S. Cognition and Innovation[M]. UK: Emerald Publishing Limited, 2018.
29 Meißner M, Oll J. The promise of eye-tracking methodology in organizational research: A taxonomy, review, and future avenues[J]. Organizational Research Methods,2019, 22(2): 590-617. DOI:10.1177/1094428117744882
30 Ng T W H, Feldman D C. Employee voice behavior: A meta-analytic test of the conservation of resources framework[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2012, 33(2): 216-234. DOI:10.1002/job.754
31 Parker S K, Bindl U K, Strauss K. Making things happen: A model of proactive motivation[J]. Journal of Management,2010, 36(4): 827-856. DOI:10.1177/0149206310363732
32 Patel P C, Messersmith J G, Lepak D P. Walking the tightrope: An assessment of the relationship between high-performance work systems and organizational ambidexterity[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2013, 56(5): 1420-1442. DOI:10.5465/amj.2011.0255
33 Pearce C L, Wassenaar C L, Berson Y, et al. Toward a theory of meta-paradoxical leadership[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2019, 155: 31-41. DOI:10.1016/j.obhdp.2019.03.003
34 Putnam L L, Fairhurst G T, Banghart S. Contradictions, dialectics, and paradoxes in organizations: A constitutive approach[J]. The Academy of Management Annals,2016, 10(1): 65-171. DOI:10.5465/19416520.2016.1162421
35 Rosing K, Frese M, Bausch A. Explaining the heterogeneity of the leadership-innovation relationship: Ambidextrous leadership[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2011, 22(5): 956-974. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2011.07.014
36 Schad J, Lewis M W, Raisch S, et al. Paradox research in management science: Looking back to move forward[J]. Academy of Management Annals,2016, 10(1): 5-64. DOI:10.5465/19416520.2016.1162422
37 Shao Y, Nijstad B A, Täuber S. Creativity under workload pressure and integrative complexity: The double-edged sword of paradoxical leadership[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2019, 155: 7-19. DOI:10.1016/j.obhdp.2019.01.008
38 Shin S J, Zhou J. When is educational specialization heterogeneity related to creativity in research and development teams? Transformational leadership as a moderator[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2007, 92(6): 1709-1721. DOI:10.1037/0021-9010.92.6.1709
39 Slawinski N, Bansal P. Short on time: Intertemporal tensions in business sustainability[J]. Organization Science,2015, 26(2): 531-549. DOI:10.1287/orsc.2014.0960
41 Smith W K. Dynamic decision making: A model of senior leaders managing strategic paradoxes[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2014, 57(6): 1592-1623. DOI:10.5465/amj.2011.0932
43 Vallerand R J, Paquet Y, Philippe F L, et al. On the role of passion for work in burnout: A process model[J]. Journal of Personality,2010, 78(1): 289-312. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-6494.2009.00616.x
44 Waldman D A, Bowen D E. Learning to be a paradox-savvy leader[J]. Academy of Management Perspectives,2016, 30(3): 316-327. DOI:10.5465/amp.2015.0070
45 Waldman D A, Putnam L L, Miron-Spektor E, et al. The role of paradox theory in decision making and management research[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2019, 155: 1-6. DOI:10.1016/j.obhdp.2019.04.006
46 Yang Y, Li Z Q, Liang L, et al. Why and when paradoxical leader behavior impact employee creativity: Thriving at work and psychological safety[J]. Current Psychology,2019. DOI:10.1007/s12144-018-0095-1
47 Zhang H Y, Ou A Y, Tsui A S, et al. CEO humility, narcissism and firm innovation: A paradox perspective on CEO traits[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2017, 28(5): 585-604. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2017.01.003
48 Zhang Y, Han Y L. Paradoxical leader behavior in long-term corporate development: Antecedents and consequences[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2019, 155: 42-54. DOI:10.1016/j.obhdp.2019.03.007
49 Zhang Y, Waldman D A, Han Y L, et al. Paradoxical leader behaviors in people management: Antecedents and consequences[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2015, 58(2): 538-566. DOI:10.5465/amj.2012.0995