后代影响了CEO的利他性偏好吗?——基于女性社会化视角的分析
Will Children Affect CEOs’ Other-Regarding Preference? A Study Based on the Angle of Female Socialization
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200630.201
[1]连燕玲,郑伟伟,高岑岑,张迪.后代影响了CEO的利他性偏好吗?——基于女性社会化视角的分析[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2020,42(10):17-32[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200630.201.
摘要
本文基于女性社会化视角,结合女性主义关怀伦理学分析了CEO后代性别对CEO利他性偏好的影响,并进一步分析了CEO的性别、CEO持股、企业制度以及所处外部环境的市场化水平对该关系的调节效应。基于2010—2018年中国沪深上市公司的数据,得出以下研究结论:第一,相对于没有养育女儿的CEO,养育女儿的CEO更具利他性偏好,具体体现为企业履行社会责任的表现更佳。第二,相对于女性CEO,男性CEO受到“女儿效应”的影响更为明显。第三,随着CEO持股增加,CEO表达利他性偏好所承担的风险随之增加,导致CEO“女儿效应”表达受限。第四,CEO由于“女儿效应”增加的利他性偏好因民企所具备的特殊制度环境而表达受限。第五,市场化程度发达地区,由于市场化导向更明显,制度规范更完善,CEO个体伦理准则和利他性偏好在企业决策中发挥的作用有限,因而“女儿效应”的表达程度被削弱。本文有助于从CEO的家庭结构视角分析其子女结构差异性对于企业社会责任决策的影响,同时也丰富了女性主义和家庭伦理等方面的研究。
The female-socialized hypothesis holds that raising a daughter affects parents’ values and behavioral preferences. Studies have shown that daughters make parents more concerned about social health and more inclined to think in terms of social care. This is called “daughter effect”. When CEOs raise a daughter, their altruistic preference will be strengthened and they will be more concerned about the welfare of social and corporate stakeholders, which will ultimately be reflected in the performance of corporate social responsibility(CSR). In other words, CEOs will pay more attention to CSR due to the “feminine socialization” effect of their daughters. Of course, other CEO personal factors and organizational factors have a moderating effect to the relationship between CEOs’ daughter raising and CSR.
Based on the perspective of female socialization, this paper discusses the relationship between CEOs’ daughter raising and CSR, and further analyzes the moderating effects of CEO gender, CEO ownership, corporate system and the marketization level of the external environment on this relationship. Based on the data of Chinese listed companies in Shanghai and Shenzhen from 2010 to 2018, we draw five conclusions: Firstly, CEOs who raise daughters perform better on CSR than those who do not. Secondly, compared with female CEOs, male CEOs raising daughters have a more significant impact on their other-regarding preference, which is specifically reflected in the better CSR performance of their companies. Thirdly, CEO shareholding has a significant inhibitory effect on the expression of “daughter effect”. Fourthly, compared with state-owned enterprises, the institutional environment of private enterprises is not conducive to the expression of “daughter effect”. Finally, compared with enterprises in high-marketization regions, the “daughter effect” of CEOs is more significant in enterprises in low-marketization regions.
The main contributions of this paper are as follows:(1)It improves relevant researches in the field of CSR, and also provides ideas for subsequent scholars to explore the decision-making characteristics of other important executives in enterprises, such as whether the other-regarding preference of the chairman is also affected by the “daughter effect”.(2)It shows that female socialization not only affects individuals, but also indirectly changes the degree of other-regarding preference in the overall behavior of enterprises, which provides a new theoretical perspective for the study of CSR and other fields of strategic management.(3)It also complements and improves the principal-agent theory to a certain extent, that is, whether a CEO raises his or her daughter can be one of the important bases for the selection of agents by the board of directors and the general meeting of shareholders.(4)From the perspective of individual level of CEOs(gender and shareholding)and the internal and external institutional environment of the organization, this paper discusses the regulating mechanism of the relationship between CEOs’ daughter raising and CSR. On the one hand, the above discussion on situational factors can supplement and improve the existing researches on the gender of CEO offspring and family structure in the field of sociology. On the other hand, it can also enhance the universality of the research conclusions of this paper.
关键词: 利他性偏好,女性社会化,女儿效应,企业社会责任